Hello Antique Mommy,
I need help. My husband and I just purchased our first home. It was built in 1976 and has the original everything. It’s hard to know where to start, but the two things that are bothering me the most are the ceiling and the fireplace in the living room. The living room is the first thing you see when you walk in our home and it sets the tone. The ceiling is a cedar tongue and groove and it continues down one wall. We don’t know if we should paint, stain, or rip it off. Also the ceilings are vaulted and there is a red brick fireplace that is floor to ceiling. I’ve painted the walls olive and it looks terrible with the red brick and cedar ceiling. HELP!!
~ Amanda
First off, congratulations Amanda on your new house! Let’s all stop and hum a few bars of “We’ve Only Just Begun.” Seriously, so much ahead of you - broken water heaters and possibly even a front door that won’t pull shut just as you are leaving for the airport. Homeownership is just a lot of fun.
Second of all, from what I’ve seen, I LOVE IT! What a fabulous view you have and I just see a ton of potential in this space.
Let’s start with the fireplace and your options and then my recommedation.
There are many many ways to reface a brick fireplace.
You can lay big 18×18 travertine/slate/granite/ceramic tiles on the diagonal for a very clean, modern look. There is also a great product out now that is a lightweight stone that comes in a variety of flavors. It really looks like a piece of stone (and trust me, I would not tell you it did if it didn’t) except that it is flat on the back like a piece of tile and it’s lightweight. You would find this product at your local brick yard. It is applied just like tile, except by a stone mason. It can even be used outside.
You can also reface your fireplace in panelled wood for an ultra-traditional library look, although I don’t think that would be a good choice for your house. As you mentioned, you can sheetrock over your fireplace, and frankly this is my least favorite option. I think it is just too modern of a look for this home. And finally you can simply paint over the existing brick, and that is my recommendation - good old fashioned paint.
I think that probably the brick on your fireplace is the same brick that is on the front of your house, so I think it would be wise to maintain that small thread of continuity. Since you have already painted your walls an olive green, I vote for painting the fireplace an olive green with a good bit of brown to it for a tone-on-tone look. Additionally, I would paint the half-bricks that surround the firebox and the hearth an even darker shade of green-brown.
Also, I would really really like to see you get a mantle on this fireplace to break up that tower of brick, something chunky and wooden to go with the ceiling. Any trim carpenter can easily do this for you. If you win the lottery, think about putting in some hand-scraped hardwoods in a dark finish. Until then a flat patterned berber in a rich green-brown would be great!
The next issue is the ceiling. Quite honestly, I would just leave it alone. When I messed with your picture in my design program, I painted it white and it just looked… dumb. If you paint it white, then it’s the only white element in the room. If you paint it green, then if you change your wall color, you are stuck with a green ceiling. No other colors look very good. At least live with it a few years before you make a decision. If at some point down the road you are able to add some hardwoods in a similar color, I think it will make a world of difference in how you feel about the ceiling.
Abpve, Amanda’s den before she painted it. I’ll bet that’s olive green paint in that bucket.
Amanda’s den after I painted it, laid some carpet and put in ugly curtains. The brown strip across the fireplace is supposed to represent a mantle.
Below is a swatch of the fabric you are planning to make into stationary panel curtains. You mentioned using bamboo or matchstick shades for privacy and I think that is a great choice – it will bring some interest and texture to the space, as opposed to standard two-inch blinds. I think the window to the left of the fireplace is going to be a challenge to dress. Maybe some of our blinds/window coverings distributors have some ideas?
Be sure to pull in the red with your accessories — pillows, art, lamps, etc. — to make this fabric work. Also, I’m thinking adding another color to your palette would really make things hum in this room - maybe yellow? What do y’all think?
The journey of a home improvement project begins with a single trip to Home Depot. And then another trip to Home Depot when you get home and find out you bought the wrong thing. And then a few trips to Lowes and maybe even one to Ace Hardware, the place with the helpful hardwareman. Come on! Sing along!
Welcome to the wonderful world of homeownership Amanda!